DetectingWales.com

just popped into Aldis and they are selling a sonic cleaner for £15-00...what do you think about using one of these to clean silver coins and other eroded coins........... 8)

Well Blind Pew...for 15 quid i would nip back down there and pick one up for that price...if it dont work then you can always give it to the Mrs for her rings..... ;D

Thanks for your reply BP i think i will.............. :D

??....... Think this guy will fit in well here :D

 ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;Dlol

put all ur dirty coins in a basket near your hi fi speakers and blast mettalica at them for half an hour,does'nt clean the coins but it does p#ss the mrs right off lol.

A very good price BP but more for cleaning jewellery and other intricate finds rather than coins. yes it will get the dirt deposits off but the blackening on silver coins is silver sulphide and needs removing electrochemically (if you must). Eroded coins are just that "eroded" and no amount of cleaning is going to put back what has been lost. Remember that any form of cleaning (other than a rinse in water) is going to strip the surface of the find even if only microscopically.
And be very careful not to use the cleaner on anything delicate as it can and sometimes does, end up in a few pieces at the bottom of the tank.

Along the same lines (sort of).
If you find a coin and show it to somebody, have you noticed how they invariably rub it between their thumb and forefinger... Arrrg.

Please don't do this.. I once did this to lovely vicky shilling I found and scratched the surface of her face. I only used a gentle motion so it doesn't take much.
Better to leave it until you get home or, do as I do now and carry a small container of soapy water and a toothbrush in the car. Even this can be fraught but you have to
make a choice as to how your going to clean at some point.

Right well I thought I was going to do a separate post for this but may as well slap it on here. I have an Ultrasonic Cleaner, found one of the best George III Sixpence's and used that as a test, and was gutted at the results, and have never used it again since. But then for the price it is always handy to have. But the other reason I add to this post is, how would you clean this Roman coin I found yesterday, so annoyed its encrusted like this, as although you cant see anything, I reckon its near mint underneath, so want to do my best not to lift the detail off. I have soaked it overnight in distilled water, and brushed off as much of the dirt that was possible, the picture shows it in this state. I am now soaking it in olive oil just to see if this will help loosen the dirt further. But does anybody have any other ways that can help. Thanks, Jon

Oh yuk jon, yep I've had them like that. Almost inland concretion. You can shift it by popping it in Phosphoric acid it will fizz as it eats up the lime that is holding the grime in place and you have to watch it. as soon as the fizzing stops you get it out.
If you go to a DIY or some builders merchants they sell it as Swarfega Metal Cleaner & Restorer

(http://i693.photobucket.com/albums/vv294/Chef_02/cleaner.jpg)

Hey Geoff, thanks for that, there is a hardware store opposite where I work, so will try there. Will this work for any metal, IE, I have a silver coin like this too, not Roman, its a Charles II Penny or Twopence, cant remember, but has the same kind of stuff on it. Never really cleaned it. Generally how long does it take, like 30 seconds or so?

Never had to use it on silver but it should be OK as it's a mild acid (I don't use gloves with it and my hands haven't fallen off yet lol) and silver being semi inert. I've cleaned Tombac buttons and buckles with it and they come up a treat.
You can also use it to kill rust as per you key and it will clean copper if you leave it long enough, though it eats the impurities which usually means if it's old you are left with a pitted coin but I'm talking about leaving it for hours.
Yes it takes between about 30 secs and 2 mins doesn't usually take any longer.

I haven't got a before and after pic so you will have to take my word for it but this one looked just as bad as your before giving it a quick soak.

(http://i693.photobucket.com/albums/vv294/Chef_02/Finds%202011%20Somerset/Picture4798.jpg)

The other thing that works well but once again you have to keep an eye on and will only take a minute or so is Electrolysis.

Well if it comes like that then I will be well pleased, cause its pointless staying like as it is. Is that a Magnentius Coin or how ever you say his name. Thanks for your help Geoff. Will let you know how I get on!

Well spotted, yes that's Mr Bigears himself.

I have used Ammonia diluted in water with a couple of drops of washing liquid. It works quite well but as with any of the chemicals used, needs to be checked until it meets your satisfaction.